Should College Athletes be Booed?

Posted by: Avinash on Thursday, May 22nd, 2008

So I’m staring at pictures of 3-4 defenses, trying to dissect what exactly to expect from next year’s defensive them, when Hydrotech comes along and troutslaps me with these nuggets from the San Francisco meeting.

*Tedford emphasized that no player on the team should ever get booed. The players are giving their best and have enough to deal with between school, practices, and the games, than to deal with negative, malicious, and non-supportive fan behavior.

I wrote about this idea in their comments, but I’m going to expand upon it here…

To think that Cal alum who have to travel from across the country to visit some of these games, who shell out ticket packages are at $100-$1200 now this year for big seats, will support their teams throughout the rough times unquestionably and dutifully regardless of the team’s continuous struggles (and unlike in previous years, the struggles were not aberrations), is a little far-fetched. Booing is usually reserved for opposing teams, but in college we often reserve our frustrations for our own athletes. Not because we don’t like our team, but it’s really hard to identify who we’re facing and who we’re playing on any given day. Can the casual fans name any of the players from the teams we faced outside of their QBs? Exactly.

I like the idea behind it, to keep sports positive to help the athletes work, but fans at Cal are pretty fairweather. There are a plethora of sporting options handed to them–Giants, Sharks, 49ers, As, Warriors are available to the locals, and others from across the country can turn to their sports. If one team fails, they move to the next one or they bemoan the time they’re wasting watching Cal. It’s not like USC/UCLA or the Deep South–Cal is in a region where pro sports trump college sports. The relative positivism of college sports fans is dissipated by the skeptic realism of pro sports fans. Whenever we suffer they take out our frustrations on the players. Sometimes it’s deserved (the last two games of the season were paaaain), but oftentimes you can’t really tell who to blame. So we boo hoping it’ll motivate the team, when often it has the opposite effect.

Now, I do think there are ways to solve this, although none of the solutions I offer are going to make Tedford very happy. The first thing I’d do is start opening up practices. As it is now, Cal fans only get their taste of the team through the 12-13 games we play every season, and the squiggles of info we grab from the Bear Insider or the Golden Blogs. Our team is a blank slate to our fans, so we learn what we know from ESPN Monday Morning Quarterbacks.

So open it up. Give access to everyone. Let’s see how hard these guys work, give them an audience that they can grow accustomed to and develop from. How much easier would it be for Cal players to handle pressure situtations if they had a crowd behind them in practice? Performing for a thousand diehards might not be the same as performing for seventy thousand, but it’s a step in the right direction for positive player development. The team needs to know the fans have their backs, rather than being an implacable mass that shows up on gameday to cheer them on.

USC holds open practices. Florida holds open practices. They haven’t done so badly have they?

Speaking of positivity…

Tedford acknowledged that the media, fan chat boards, and bloggers must remain positive because it does and has had an effect on recruiting.

Now I agree about this…for the most part. I think sometimes we get carried away by terrible spins, because then our passion feels like a labor, a job, a painful job. I even got sick from it last year. It’s even worse than being the casual fan who boos, because you have to try to write about it with a level head. And it’s hard.

However, to say that media, message boards and bloggers have had an effect on recruiting probably has some faulty reasoning behind it. Are recruits really saying no because Blogger Madmen like me wrote up on unconfirmed (and I emphasize “UNCONFIRMED”) rumors of players quitting on Tedford back in November? Or are recruits saying no because Cal let Washington run up 340 yards on them, never put up more than 23 points in the last six games of the season with some of the best offensive talent in the league, and stumbled from #1 in the country to the Armed Forces Bowl?

A 1-6 collapse speaks for itself.

I don’t have much of an opinion about the question above (I only get disgusted when players do something stupid), so I turn the discussion over to my readers: Should college athletes be booed? Why or why not?

(Image from Play in CA)



Topics: Blogs, cal athletics, Cal Football, Coaching, Players

Related Articles
    None Found

Comments (5)

Loading... Logging you in...
Dashboard | Edit profile | Logout
  • Logged in as
Login or signup now to comment.
0 Vote up Vote down
BeastMode's avatar - Go to profile

BeastMode · 879 weeks ago

Well, I think you know my opinion on this matter. You shouldn't boo your own college team. Period. They are not professionals, they are kids, for the most part one's that will receive a degree from Cal. The do get more leeway and they should.

I do think you're conflating issues: whether fans do boo and whether they should.

Also, as for the ridiculous proposition of someone traveling from across the country and only doing so if the team is successful, well, I guess I am one of those persons. I'm a loyal person, hell, I'm from Buffalo. I will love my friends and family until the end. Same goes for my hometown, college, and sports teams. Maybe we are just different this way, but yeah, I will support the team when it fails. After all, I did go to EVERY home game in 2001 when Cal fell to 1-10.
Reply
0 Vote up Vote down
Avinash's avatar - Go to profile

Avinash · 879 weeks ago

Well, my team is the Bills (I was born there). But they've caused so much heartbreak to me that it's hard for me to get attached to another team.

I take a much harder view with Cal than I do with Buffalo as a result of the failings my hometown team has undergone (that Dallas-Buffalo game made me hate life a thousand ways over), and perhaps that's unjust. But I've matured since I was a kid, and I've learned support only gets you so far. You have to be critical when it's due and sometimes (albeit rarely I admit), negative. I'm a little cynical in that sense, but I'm not going to just smell sunshine and roses all the time.

I'll support the team when it fails, but only by pointing out why the team is failing. There's only so much failure one can take. And I don't think general Cal fans will boo that much when the going gets rough. They just won't show up.
Reply
0 Vote up Vote down
HydroTech's avatar - Go to profile

HydroTech · 879 weeks ago

As for opening up practices, do we really need to do that just so fans can truly understand how hard the players work? Do you really need to see it for yourself? Just knowing that the players have a greater fall workload than any other Cal student on campus isn't enough? Must you get a copy of their fall daily schedule to see how many hours per day they devote to football until you can believe that they truly work hard?

As for the whole USC and Florida running open practices argument. The flaw with that argument is that those teams are USC and Florida. They are powerhouses. They are stocked with 4 and 5 star talent. Their second stringers could probably destroy the bottom half of teams in the NCAA. My point: they don't have to worry as much with their opponents knowing what they are doing because they are talented enough to get by with the other team knowing. For teams that are less talented, secrecy truly is valued more.
Reply
0 Vote up Vote down
BeastMode's avatar - Go to profile

BeastMode · 879 weeks ago

I guess my attitude has changed a bit since I left Buffalo, I've become a bit more positive. And, let me tell you that Dallas-Buffalo game was absolute torture. It had been so long since MNF had gone to Buffalo. The fans were awesome. The city looked fantastic. It was the worst loss since the Music City Miracle. Jesus, I have seen so many terrible Bills losses, nothing Cal can do can equal those.
Reply
0 Vote up Vote down
Reno Bear's avatar

Reno Bear · 879 weeks ago

No one should be booing our own players. I was really pissed when people would boo Ayoob. As much as I wanted to boo Longshore I kept my mouth shut. These are college kids playing for their school. If you want to boo go to a pro game.Those guys get paid to get boo's.
Reply

Comments by